Summary:
The five schools serving zip code 32425 in Bonifay, FL, all part of the Holmes County School District, serve a high-poverty community (average 60.4% free/reduced lunch) and face a systemic crisis of chronic absenteeism, with an average rate of 41.7% across brick-and-mortar schools.
The most surprising standout is Bethlehem High School, an alternative school that consistently outperforms the district and often the state in key subjects like Biology 1 (86% proficient) and US History (80% proficient), challenging the assumption that alternative settings are for lower performers. In contrast, Graduation Assistance Program (GAP) is in a state of emergency, with an 80.5% chronic absenteeism rate, a 44.4% graduation rate, and 0% proficiency in 8th-grade science and math. Bonifay K-8 School and Holmes County High School show a paradox: Holmes County High has a stellar 96.3% graduation rate but very low proficiency (only 16% proficient in Algebra 1), suggesting students may graduate without mastering core subjects. Holmes Virtual-Franchise FLVS operates differently with the lowest spending ($2,066 per student) and lowest absenteeism (2.4%), but its 30% graduation rate indicates it serves a highly specialized population.
Key takeaways: Spending does not equal success—Bethlehem High spends the most ($13,987) and performs best, while GAP spends $10,743 and performs worst. Chronic absenteeism is the single most critical factor holding the district back, with rates far exceeding the state average of 31.4%. The district ranks 55th out of 70 in Florida (21st percentile), earning a 1-star rating, highlighting significant systemic challenges that parents should consider when evaluating school options in this area.
Thank you for your feedback!