Summary:
There are two middle schools in zip code 32351 (Quincy, FL), James A. Shanks Middle School and West Gadsden Middle School, both serving grades 4 through 8 within the Gadsden District, which ranks in the bottom 10% of Florida districts.
While both schools face significant challenges, James A. Shanks Middle School generally outperforms West Gadsden Middle School in grade-level assessments and holds a slightly higher state ranking (12th percentile vs. 11th percentile). However, the most striking finding is the "advanced course paradox": despite low overall rankings, both schools achieve exceptional proficiency in advanced subjects. For example, Shanks posted 91% proficiency in Algebra 1 and 86% in Biology 1, far exceeding state averages. West Gadsden also showed a unique strength in Geometry (47% proficient). This suggests that the small group of students placed in advanced tracks are exceptionally well-prepared, creating a stark contrast with low performance in standard grade-level subjects.
The dominant challenge is chronic absenteeism, with rates near 55-57% at both schools—nearly double the state average. This likely explains the low proficiency in core subjects like 5th-grade Science (13-16% proficient). Interestingly, West Gadsden Middle School spends over $2,000 more per student ($15,877 vs. $13,819) than James A. Shanks Middle School, yet its test scores are generally weaker, indicating that financial resources alone are not a solution. Year-over-year performance is also highly volatile, with 8th-grade Science scores at both schools dropping dramatically (e.g., from 40% to 8% at West Gadsden), suggesting performance depends heavily on specific student cohorts. For parents, the key takeaway is that while these schools have pockets of excellence in advanced coursework, addressing chronic absenteeism is the foundational issue for overall improvement.
Thank you for your feedback!