Best High Schools in Zip Code 32259

Zip code 32259 in Saint Johns, Florida, is home to three large, high-performing public high schools—Creekside High School, Beachside High School, and Bartram Trail High School—all serving grades 8 through 12 within the top-ranked St. Johns County School District.

Creekside High School stands out as the top performer in the area, ranking 37th in Florida and earning a 5-star rating. It leads in nearly every academic metric, including 97% proficiency in Biology and 90% in Geometry, and boasts the lowest chronic absenteeism rate at 14.9%—far better than the district average of 20.1%. Beachside High School is a strong second, ranking 74th and also earning a 5-star rating, with notable strength in Geometry (81% proficiency) and a clear upward trend in its state ranking. Bartram Trail High School ranks 87th with a 4-star rating but excels in Algebra 1 (85% proficiency) and has the highest graduation rate in the zip code at 99.2%. All three schools significantly outperform state averages in test scores and graduation rates, though they sometimes fall slightly below the high district benchmarks.

Key takeaways for parents include that Creekside offers the most consistent academic excellence and student engagement, while Beachside is rapidly improving and Bartram Trail provides top-tier graduation outcomes and math proficiency. Spending per student varies, with Creekside at $9,112, Bartram Trail at $8,361, and Beachside at $7,939, but this does not directly predict performance. Chronic absenteeism is a major differentiator, with Creekside’s low rate suggesting a highly engaged school culture. Overall, families in this zip code have access to three excellent schools, each with unique strengths, all within one of Florida’s best school districts.