Summary:
Zip code 32221 in Jacksonville, Florida, is home to two middle schools, Chaffee Trail Middle School and Joseph Stilwell Middle School, both serving grades 6-8 within the Duval County school district, which ranks in the bottom third of Florida districts.
These two schools present a stark contrast in resources and performance patterns. Chaffee Trail Middle School is the larger school with 1,190 students, but it struggles with consistent underperformance across most standard subjects like ELA and Math, likely tied to its high student-teacher ratio of 29.7:1 and lower spending of $7,741 per student. In contrast, Joseph Stilwell Middle School spends significantly more ($13,669 per student) and has a much lower student-teacher ratio of 15.7:1, which fuels exceptional results in advanced coursework—94% proficiency in Algebra 1 and 86% in Biology 1. However, Stilwell's overall state ranking is nearly identical to Chaffee Trail's, largely due to a crisis-level chronic absenteeism rate of 53.7%, which is far above the state average of 31.4% and likely drags down its general grade-level performance.
For parents, the key takeaway is that neither school offers a uniformly strong experience. Joseph Stilwell Middle School is a "two-speed" school: it excels for advanced students in high-school-level courses but struggles with basic proficiency in 7th-grade Math (15%) and 8th-grade Science (20%). Chaffee Trail Middle School shows consistent, systemic underperformance across the board, with a lone bright spot in Biology 1 (97% proficiency). Both schools face challenges rooted in district-wide issues, but the stark differences in spending and attendance highlight that local factors are critical. Parents should prioritize understanding their child's academic needs and the specific programs at each school.
Thank you for your feedback!