Summary
Summerlake Elementary in Winter Garden, FL, is a high-performing K-5 school serving 726 students in a community where only 8.4% of students qualify for free or reduced lunch, and it has earned a 5-star rating from SchoolDigger for four of the last five years. This school stands out for its exceptional academic proficiency, with 3rd and 4th grade math scores reaching 96% and 95% in the 2025-2026 school year—about 30 percentage points above the state average. While nearby schools like Whispering Oak Elementary and Hamlin Elementary are also top-tier, Summerlake’s performance is uniformly high across all subjects, with its lowest proficiency score at 80% (5th grade science and math), showing no significant weak spots.
One of the most striking features of Summerlake is its remarkably low chronic absenteeism rate of just 8.3% in the 2023-2024 school year, far below the Orange district average of 35.2% and the state average of 31.4%. This rate is also lower than its high-performing peers, such as Hamlin Elementary (11.8%) and Whispering Oak (11.4%), suggesting a highly engaged student body and strong family support. Additionally, Summerlake achieves these results with efficient spending of $10,217 per student, less than several neighboring schools like Sunset Park Elementary ($12,062) and Whispering Oak ($11,956), indicating excellent resource allocation.
Summerlake is part of a remarkable cluster of elite schools in the Winter Garden/Windermere area, including Whispering Oak, Hamlin, and Keenes Crossing Elementary, all within a 4-mile radius and earning 5-star ratings. However, a notable pattern is a "5th-grade slump," where math proficiency drops from 96% in 3rd grade to 80% in 5th grade, possibly due to increased curriculum complexity. When compared to nearby Panther Lake Elementary, which has a similar poverty rate (11.04%) but ranks in the 57th percentile, Summerlake’s 97th percentile ranking highlights a significant "value-add" from its leadership, teaching quality, and parental involvement, making it a destination school in the district.
Thank you for your feedback!