Summary
Imater Academy Middle School in Hialeah, FL, serves 783 students in grades 6-8 within the Miami-Dade school district, a community where 76.6% of students qualify for free or reduced lunch. This school presents a striking paradox: it excels in advanced coursework while struggling with grade-level proficiency, creating a "tale of two schools" under one roof. For instance, in 2025-2026, Imater achieved 93% proficiency in Geometry and 92% in Biology 1 End-of-Course exams, far outpacing district and state averages. However, only 27% of 8th graders were proficient in grade-level Science, and 45% in 8th-grade Math, both well below state benchmarks. This gap suggests that while the school offers an exceptional program for students in advanced tracks, the general student body faces significant challenges in core subjects.
Compared to its nearest neighbor, Henry H. Filer Middle School (just 0.57 miles away), Imater is a much stronger option across the board. Imater outperforms Filer in every grade-level FAST subject, such as 6th-grade ELA (66% vs. 39%) and 7th-grade Math (73% vs. 40%), and also leads in advanced courses like Algebra 1 (79% vs. 58%). However, when compared to a top performer like Mater Academy Charter Middle School (73rd percentile), Imater falls short in grade-level Math, especially in 8th grade (45% vs. 92%), and has a higher chronic absenteeism rate (34.6% vs. 27.6%). This indicates that while Imater is a solid choice relative to some local schools, it has room to improve in supporting all students.
A critical concern is Imater's rising chronic absenteeism, which has more than doubled from 14.0% in 2019-2020 to 34.6% in 2023-2024, exceeding both district and state averages. This likely contributes to the school's overall decline from a 3-star rating and 62nd percentile in 2018-2019 to a 2-star rating and 49th percentile in 2025-2026. Despite spending a relatively low $8,861 per student, Imater achieves better results than schools like Palm Springs Middle School ($18,608 per student), suggesting efficient use of resources. For parents, Imater is an excellent fit for students who qualify for advanced courses, but families should be aware of the school's struggles with grade-level proficiency and attendance, which may require extra support for the average learner.
Thank you for your feedback!