Summary:
The four public middle schools in the Highlands district serve grades 6-8 and enroll between 507 and 840 students each, with the district itself ranking 43rd out of 70 in Florida and earning a 2-star rating.
Two schools stand out for very different reasons. Lake Placid Middle School is the district's top improver, jumping from the 37th to the 48th percentile in state rankings over three years, and it achieved a perfect 100% proficiency rate on the Algebra 1 EOC exam. However, it also has the highest chronic absenteeism rate in the district at 47.4%, meaning nearly half its students are chronically absent. In contrast, Avon Park Middle School consistently ranks lowest, sitting in the 27th percentile with a 1-star rating, and it has the highest percentage of students on free/reduced lunch (70.33%). Hill-Gustat Middle School spends the most per student ($14,522) but does not have the highest academic rankings, while Sebring Middle School spends the least ($10,071) yet ranks higher than Hill-Gustat, showing that higher spending does not guarantee better outcomes.
A major district-wide issue is chronic absenteeism, with all four schools exceeding the state average of 31.4%. Another interesting finding is the "Algebra 1 Anomaly": all schools dramatically outperform state averages on the Algebra 1 EOC (86% to 100% proficiency), yet most struggle with standard grade-level math on the FAST exams. This suggests that students taking Algebra 1 in middle school are a highly advanced group. Overall, Lake Placid Middle School presents a contradiction—it has the highest absenteeism and high economic need, yet shows the strongest upward trend, indicating effective interventions may be overcoming significant challenges.
Thank you for your feedback!