Summary:
Zip code 06511 in New Haven, Connecticut is served by six public high schools — Wilbur Cross High School, James Hillhouse High School, Cooperative High School - Inter-District Magnet, Metropolitan Business Academy, New Haven Academy, and High School In The Community — all serving grades 9 through 12 within the New Haven School District, which ranks 143rd out of 153 in the state. Together these schools enroll 4,378 students, from 251 at High School In The Community to 1,742 at Wilbur Cross. All serve predominantly low-income populations, with free/reduced lunch rates between 63% and 81%, and all face chronic absenteeism of about 41% on average, far above the state average of 16.4%.
Cooperative High School - Inter-District Magnet is the strongest all-around performer, with the highest graduation rate at 93.2%, the strongest SAT ELA proficiency, and the best state ranking in the group. New Haven Academy is the attendance and math standout, with the lowest chronic absenteeism (26.6%) and the only math scores above the district average. Metropolitan Business Academy and High School In The Community post strong graduation rates and above-average science scores, though their overall state rankings remain low. The two largest schools, Wilbur Cross High School and James Hillhouse High School, are the most challenged, with graduation rates of 74.6% and 69.1%, well below the district average of 79.9%.
Several patterns emerge. Smaller schools tend to have better graduation rates: the four smallest schools all graduate above 82%, while the two largest lag behind. However, high graduation does not always translate into strong state rankings, since rankings are driven primarily by test proficiency rather than graduation outcomes. Chronic absenteeism is the most consistent problem, affecting even the strongest school at more than double the state rate. Test scores are also volatile year to year — Cooperative's ELA proficiency dropped from 45.7% to 26.4% in a single year — so families should look at multiple years rather than any single ranking. Overall, Cooperative High School - Inter-District Magnet offers the best mix of graduation success and academics, while the large comprehensive high schools face the steepest challenges.
Thank you for your feedback!