Summary:
Regional School District 04 in Connecticut serves two schools—Valley Regional High School (grades 9–12) and John Winthrop Middle School (grades 7–8)—with a combined enrollment of 626 students. The district as a whole is rated 2 stars, though both individual schools currently hold 3-star ratings and rank in the 62nd–66th percentile among their respective school types.
Parents will find notable strengths in this small district. Valley Regional High School posts an exceptional 97.4% graduation rate, well above the state’s 91.2%, and its 11th-grade ELA and science proficiency scores (68% and 63.5%) comfortably beat state averages. The high school’s math proficiency, however, sits right at the state average (31.1%), a sharp drop from the middle school’s math performance. John Winthrop Middle School also outpaces the state in most subjects, with 8th-grade ELA at 61.6% vs. 51.1% and 8th-grade math at 47.7% vs. 41.9%. Chronic absenteeism is a district strength: only 9.0% at the middle school and 13.0% at the high school, compared to the 16.4% state average. Both schools serve similar socioeconomic populations, with about 26–27% of students eligible for free/reduced lunch.
One key concern is the broad year-over-year decline in 2025-26, especially at the middle school, where 7th-grade math fell 10.2 points and 8th-grade math fell 9.0 points. Even with small cohorts of roughly 100 students per grade—which can make single-year swings look dramatic—the consistency of the drop suggests something worth watching. The high school saw smaller declines in ELA and math but improved in science by 4.3 points. Finally, a per-student spending figure listed as $53,789 for John Winthrop Middle School (vs. $3,132 for the high school) is almost certainly a data reporting artifact and should be ignored for school comparisons. Overall, this district offers strong graduation rates, solid attendance, and above-average middle school academics, but math proficiency at the high school and recent test-score dips are areas to monitor.
Thank you for your feedback!