Summary:
Regional School District 14 includes two elementary schools — Mitchell Elementary School and Bethlehem Elementary School — serving approximately 604 students in pre-kindergarten through grade 5 across the Connecticut towns of Woodbury and Bethlehem.
Bethlehem Elementary School is the clear standout. It ranks 85th out of 491 Connecticut elementary schools (83rd percentile, 4 stars), while Mitchell Elementary School ranks 170th (65th percentile, 3 stars). Bethlehem outperforms Mitchell in nearly every tested subject and grade. Its 4th grade math proficiency rate of 86% is 34 points above the state average, and its 3rd grade ELA and math scores are well above both district and state averages. Mitchell does have bright spots — its 5th grade science score (72.3% proficient) and 5th grade math score (68.1%) are strong, and it has improved from the 51st to the 65th percentile in three years. Still, the gap between the two schools is large, especially in 3rd and 4th grade ELA and math.
Both schools serve similar student populations — free/reduced lunch eligibility is nearly identical (19.5% at Mitchell, 19.2% at Bethlehem) — so differences in outcomes are especially notable. Chronic absenteeism is a key differentiator: Bethlehem’s rate is just 5.7%, less than half the state average of 16.4%, while Mitchell’s is 9.2%. Mitchell’s 3rd grade scores swung dramatically from 2024–2025 to 2025–2026, jumping about 27–29 points in ELA and math, a reminder that small cohorts can create year-to-year volatility. Bethlehem, meanwhile, has steadily climbed into the top fifth of Connecticut elementary schools over the past three years. For parents comparing the two, Bethlehem offers more consistent, top-tier academic performance, while Mitchell is a solidly improving school with particular strengths in science and 5th grade math. One note: Bethlehem did not report 5th grade math proficiency for 2025–2026, so that subject-grade combination cannot be compared directly.
Thank you for your feedback!