Summary:
This analysis examines three public elementary schools (Alta Heights, Phillips, and Shearer) serving grades K-5 and K-8 within the Napa Valley Unified district in zip code 94559 of Napa, California, revealing significant differences in performance and environment.
Alta Heights Elementary stands out as the highest-performing school in the area, with test scores close to California averages, a solid state ranking, and the lowest chronic absenteeism rate at 13.9%. In contrast, Shearer Elementary faces considerable challenges, with the lowest test scores, a state ranking in the bottom 10%, and a very high chronic absenteeism rate of 29.2%. Phillips Elementary falls in the middle, performing better than Shearer but still below state and district averages.
The data shows a strong link between economic disadvantage and academic outcomes, with the two lower-performing schools having much higher percentages of students qualifying for free or reduced-price lunch. Notably, per-student funding and class size do not directly correlate with success, as the school with the most resources is not the top performer. For parents, this highlights that while Alta Heights is a relative strength within the district, the area's schools overall serve communities with varying needs, and chronic absenteeism is a critical issue impacting performance at the struggling schools.
Thank you for your feedback!