Summary:
Schools in ZIP code 93454 include 12 schools—nine elementary schools, one middle school, and two high schools—mostly in Santa Maria-Bonita, with high schools in Santa Maria Joint Union High and Benjamin Foxen Elementary in Blochman Union Elementary; the clearest standout in the supplied results is Foxen.
Benjamin Foxen Elementary led all 12 schools in All Grades English language arts (ELA) at 48% and math at 33%, and was the only school above the state in science, with 40% versus 36%. The lowest results vary by subject: Alvin Elementary was lowest in ELA at 18%, Fesler Junior High in math at 12%, and Bill Libbon Elementary in science at 10%. Among the high schools, Pioneer Valley High led Santa Maria High in ELA by 2 points and science by 3 points; their math scores were close, 19.7% and 19.4%. Pioneer also had a 95% graduation rate and 4% dropout rate, compared with 87% and 9% at Santa Maria.
Recent changes were mixed: the unweighted average across the 12 schools fell by 1 point in ELA and rose by 1 point in math and 2 points in science from 2024–2025 to 2025–2026; some schools, including Fesler, improved in all three subjects. SchoolDigger ranked Foxen in the 58th percentile for 2025–2026, compared with the 4th–25th percentiles for the Santa Maria-Bonita schools in this list. For context, 2024–2025 free/reduced lunch eligible figures ranged from 45% at Foxen to 98% at Alvin; these are observations, not explanations for score differences. Foxen had just 210 students, while enrollment at Santa Maria High was 3,143. All Grades results are broad snapshots because schools serve different grade spans.
Thank you for your feedback!