Summary:
ZIP code 93453 has two K–5 elementary schools, both in Atascadero Unified, with enrollments ranging from 21 to 297 students. Their 2025–2026 results vary considerably, especially in mathematics: Santa Margarita Elementary scored 57% and Carrisa Plains Elementary scored 18%, a 39-point difference. That mathematics gap is the clearest finding about these schools.
Santa Margarita stands out for results above the state in all three reported subjects: by 4 points in ELA, 19 in mathematics, and 26 in science. Carrisa Plains is below the state by 20 points in mathematics, the only all-grades result available for comparison; its ELA and science results are suppressed and cannot be compared. Santa Margarita’s strongest grade-level result relative to the state was fifth-grade science, at 62% versus 35%, while its weakest was fourth-grade ELA, at 33% versus 46%. Its ELA results also vary by grade: third grade was 55% and fifth grade 71%, both above the state.
Santa Margarita’s results improved in mathematics and science from 2024–2025 to 2025–2026, but declined in ELA: mathematics rose from 53% to 57%, science from 42% to 62%, and ELA fell from 57% to 53%. Its lead over the state grew by 3 points in mathematics and 17 in science, while its ELA lead narrowed by 5 points. SchoolDigger’s percentile rose from 72 to 75 over the same three-year period, even as the latest ELA score fell. Other differences may matter to families: 2025–2026 chronic absenteeism was 10% at Santa Margarita and 39% at Carrisa Plains; 2024–2025 free/reduced lunch eligible figures were 34% and 76%, respectively. Carrisa Plains also had a lower student-teacher ratio (10.6 versus 25.6) and higher per-student spending ($49,406 versus $16,788); these are observations, not explanations for test results.
Thank you for your feedback!