Summary
Carl Smith Middle serves 262 students in grades 6–8 in Terra Bella, within the Terra Bella Union Elementary district; it has the smallest enrollment among the nine nearby schools compared. The clearest concern is science: just 16% of students were proficient in 2025–2026, compared with 36% statewide.
English language arts is Carl Smith’s relative bright spot, while science is its largest shortfall. ELA proficiency was 39%, about 1 point above the district (39.3% versus 38.6%), but 10 points below the state and 4 points below the nearby-school average of 43%. Math proficiency was 24%—5 points below the district, 15 below the state, and 3 below the nearby average. Science was essentially level with the district (15.6% versus 15.2%), but 20 points below the state and 10 below the nearby average. Among nearby schools serving grades 6–8, Carl Smith had the lowest ELA and science results and the second-lowest math results.
Results have not kept pace with state gains: from 2022–2023 to 2025–2026, Carl Smith’s ELA proficiency fell 5 points, math was nearly unchanged, and science fell 1 point, while its gaps with the state widened to 10 points in ELA, 15 in math, and 20 in science. SchoolDigger places the school at the 34th statewide percentile with 2 stars, down from the 50th percentile in 2022–2023; the district is at the 31st percentile with 2 stars. One notable exception in SchoolDigger’s group rankings is English Language Learner Students: the school ranked at the 89th percentile in 2023–2024, compared with its overall 44th percentile that year. In 2024–2025, 93% of students were free/reduced lunch eligible, and the student–teacher ratio was 20.1. Chronic absenteeism was 20% in 2025–2026, above the district’s 17%, the state’s 18%, and the nearby-school average of 14%.
Thank you for your feedback!