Summary
El Carmelo Elementary serves 282 students in kindergarten through grade 5 in Palo Alto, where nearby elementary schools also have strong academic results. The school’s proficiency rates are above California’s in English language arts (ELA), math, and science, but below both the district and nearby-school averages in all three. The most important finding for families comparing local options is that El Carmelo ranks near the bottom of its nearby K–5 peers in ELA and math.
Science is El Carmelo’s strongest subject relative to the district and state, while math has the largest gaps against the district and nearby schools. In 2025–2026, proficiency was 71% in ELA, 68% in math, and 70% in science; state rates were 49%, 38%, and 36%, respectively. But the nearby-school averages were 80% in ELA, 82% in math, and 78% in science, leaving El Carmelo 9, 14, and 9 percentage points behind. Its science rate was 5 points below the district, the smallest district gap of the three subjects. Grade-level results also show specific areas to watch: grade 4 ELA was 64%, 13 points below both the nearby-school and district rates, while grade 3 math was 65%, 18 points below the nearby-school average and 17 below the district.
Scores have declined since 2022–2023: ELA fell 4 percentage points, math 10, and science 8, even as state rates rose, narrowing El Carmelo’s lead over California. SchoolDigger ranked the school at the 90th statewide percentile with 4 stars in 2025–2026; eight of its nine nearby K–5 schools had 5 stars. SchoolDigger’s rankings for student groups were notably lower: Low Socio Economic Status Students ranked at the 31st percentile and Hispanic Students at the 30th, compared with the school’s overall 90th-percentile rank. In 2024–2025, 18% of students were free/reduced lunch eligible, and the student–teacher ratio was 19.2, close to the nearby-school average of 19.4. Chronic absenteeism was 8% in 2025–2026, below the district’s 10% and California’s 18%.
Thank you for your feedback!