Summary
Toby Johnson Middle serves 1,317 students in grades 7–8 in Elk Grove, where families can compare it with several nearby middle schools. In 2025–26, its proficiency rates were higher than both district and state rates in English language arts (ELA), math and science. The key takeaway is that the school performs strongly across all three subjects, though it is not the local leader.
ELA is its strongest area against same-grade nearby schools, while science is its weakest: proficiency was 66% in ELA, 54% in math and 44% in science, compared with nearby-school averages of 52%, 41% and 34%. It ranked third among nine schools in ELA and fourth in math and science. Its rates also topped Elk Grove Unified by 12, 10 and 7 percentage points, and the state by 17, 15 and 8 points, respectively. Elizabeth Pinkerton Middle and Katherine L. Albiani Middle scored higher in all three subjects; Joseph Kerr Middle also scored higher in math and science. Chronic absenteeism is another relative strength: 14%, compared with 22% districtwide and 18% statewide; only Pinkerton had a lower rate among nearby schools.
Proficiency has improved since 2022–23, rising by 3 percentage points in ELA, 3 in math and 4 in science. However, ELA and math dipped slightly in the latest year, and the school’s lead over the state barely changed in those subjects; its science lead narrowed by 2 points. SchoolDigger ranked the school at the 83rd percentile, with four stars, in 2025–26—third-highest by percentile among the listed nearby schools. Context includes a student-teacher ratio of 22.8 in 2024–25, tied for the highest among nearby schools, and 45% of students eligible for free/reduced lunch in 2024–25, below the 63% average among its eight same-district peers. SchoolDigger’s statewide effectiveness ranking for Asian Students was at the 43rd percentile, versus the school’s overall 83rd; for Special Education Students, it rose from the 59th percentile in 2023–24 to the 75th in 2025–26.
Thank you for your feedback!