Summary:
This analysis examines five middle schools within the Santa Rosa High district in California for the 2024-2025 school year, serving grades 5-8, where a significant performance gap exists between a standout charter school and the traditional public schools.
Santa Rosa Accelerated Charter is the clear top performer, with over 80% of students proficient in all subjects and a remarkably low chronic absenteeism rate of 3.9%. Among traditional schools, Rincon Valley Middle is the strongest, with test scores above district and state averages. In contrast, Hilliard Comstock Middle faces considerable challenges, with proficiency rates below 15% in all subjects and the highest chronic absenteeism. Herbert Slater Middle and Santa Rosa Middle fall in the middle, with performance near or below district averages.
Key insights show that higher per-student spending does not guarantee better results, and chronic absenteeism is a major concern, exceeding the state average at four of the five schools. The district's math scores are notably below the state average, indicating a widespread challenge. The stability of school rankings over recent years suggests these performance patterns are persistent, with the charter school's success highlighting potential differences in instructional models or student engagement strategies.
Thank you for your feedback!