Summary:
The seven schools in Petaluma City Elementary include six elementary schools serving K–6 and South County Consortium, an alternative school serving K–12. The latest results are from 2025–26 for five elementary schools and South County Consortium; the five-school elementary average was 46% in ELA, 43% in math and 32% in science. The clearest takeaway is that those averages hide a wide divide between schools, rather than describing one consistent experience across the area.
Grant Elementary led the five elementary schools with 2025–26 results, scoring 72% in ELA, 70% in math and 49% in science; McNear Elementary was a strong runner-up at 58%, 57% and 48%. Both were above state results in all three subjects. At the other end, McDowell Elementary scored 9% in ELA, 13% in math and 10% in science—below the state by 40, 26 and 26 percentage points, respectively. Grant’s lead over McDowell was 63 points in ELA, 58 in math and 39 in science.
The five-school average declined from 2024–25 to 2025–26 in ELA, math and science, while the average gap with the state widened by 1, 2 and 4 points, respectively. SchoolDigger rankings show a similar contrast: Grant was at the 89th percentile and McNear at the 77th in 2025–26, compared with McDowell at the 2nd percentile. In 2024–25, free/reduced lunch eligible students made up 18% at Grant and 86% at McDowell; these figures offer context, not an explanation for results. Enrollment and ratios do not neatly account for the differences: Grant and McDowell had student-teacher ratios of 24.1:1 and 23.5:1, while McNear’s was 22.8:1. South County Consortium scored 14% in ELA and 15% in math in 2025–26; Valley Vista’s latest supplied test results are from 2024–25, and South County Consortium’s K–12 alternative setting is not directly comparable with the elementary schools.
Thank you for your feedback!