Summary:
The El Dorado School District in Arkansas is home to two middle schools—Washington Middle School (serving grades 5-6) and Barton Junior High School (serving grades 5-8)—both of which serve a student population where over 65% qualify for free or reduced lunch, and the district itself holds a 3-star rating.
Barton Junior High School stands out for its exceptional Algebra program, achieving a remarkable 95.2% proficiency rate in the 2025-2026 school year—far exceeding the district average of 51.5% and the state average of 36.9%. This suggests a highly effective advanced math track for 8th graders. Barton also improved its state ranking from a 2-star to a 3-star rating over the past year. In contrast, Washington Middle School offers stability and consistency, with a slightly lower student-teacher ratio (13.3:1) compared to Barton (11.8:1), which can benefit younger students. While Barton outperforms Washington in nearly every core subject—including English Language Arts (36.6% vs. 33.6%), Reading (39.9% vs. 35.0%), and Science (40.9% vs. 34.8%)—Washington showed a dramatic 15-percentage-point improvement in Math proficiency from 23.6% to 38.5% year-over-year.
Both schools have nearly identical per-student spending ($13,802 vs. $13,803), yet Barton’s stronger outcomes, especially in advanced math, point to factors like curriculum and teaching quality driving the difference. A notable finding is the "5th grade dip" at Washington, where 5th graders scored lower than 6th graders across all subjects, possibly reflecting a challenging transition into middle school. Meanwhile, Barton’s 8th graders consistently outperform state averages in Math (48.7% vs. 36.2%) and Reading (41.5% vs. 38.4%), indicating strong high school preparation. Overall, Barton excels in specialized programs and upward momentum, while Washington provides a solid, improving foundation for younger students.
Thank you for your feedback!