Summary:
Zip code 36606 in Mobile, Alabama is served by two elementary schools within the Mobile County district, together educating 932 students in grades PK-5, yet these two schools offer vastly different educational experiences. Eichold-Mertz School of Math and Science is an elite, top-performing institution, while Spencer-Westlawn Elementary School faces significant academic and socioeconomic challenges.
For parents, the choice between these two schools is stark. Eichold-Mertz has earned a 5-star rating for three consecutive years and ranks 4th out of 686 elementary schools in Alabama, with proficiency rates above 88% in nearly every subject and grade. In contrast, Spencer-Westlawn holds a 1-star rating and ranks in the bottom third of the state, with 4th-grade math proficiency at just 18.57% compared to Eichold-Mertz's 88.10%. The achievement gap is most dramatic in 4th-grade science, where Eichold-Mertz students score 95.24% proficient versus just 23.19% at Spencer-Westlawn. A major factor is poverty: 90.19% of Spencer-Westlawn students qualify for free/reduced lunch versus 38.1% at Eichold-Mertz. Notably, Spencer-Westlawn actually spends $719 more per student, yet this additional funding has not closed the gap.
Several other insights stand out. Eichold-Mertz boasts an extraordinarily low chronic absenteeism rate of 1.4%—nearly nine times lower than the state average—and shows remarkable year-over-year consistency in test scores. Spencer-Westlawn shows a troubling "middle school slide," with math proficiency dropping from 40.63% in 3rd grade to 18.57% in 4th grade, though its English/Language Arts performance is a relative strength, with 5th-grade proficiency at 64.91%—actually exceeding the district average. Despite having a higher student-teacher ratio and lower per-student spending, Eichold-Mertz achieves dramatically superior outcomes, suggesting its success stems from effective resource utilization, specialized curriculum, and strong school culture rather than simply more funding.
Thank you for your feedback!