Summary:
The Fayette County school district in Alabama contains two high schools serving grades 9-12 (with one also covering grades 7-8), and the two schools present a stark contrast in performance despite serving nearly identical student populations—both with about 54% of students qualifying for free or reduced lunch.
Fayette County High School is the clear leader, showing consistent improvement in its state ranking over three years, climbing from the 65th percentile to the 73rd percentile (4 stars). It boasts a 92.5% graduation rate—30.5 percentage points higher than Berry High School's alarming 62% rate. Fayette County also outperforms Berry in every 11th-grade subject, with the largest gap in science (40.74% vs. 25.71% proficiency). Most impressively, Fayette County nearly doubled its math proficiency in one year, jumping from 15.96% to 29.63%. Its chronic absenteeism rate of 11.7% is also healthier than Berry's 15.8%.
Berry High School tells a more volatile story. After a catastrophic drop to a 1-star rating in 2024-2025, it partially recovered to a 2-star rating, though it remains far below its earlier performance. Berry's 11th-grade scores improved dramatically from very low baselines (math went from 2.33% to 20% proficiency), but the school's biggest concern is the "middle school success, high school failure" pattern—its 7th-grade English proficiency is 66%, yet by 11th grade it falls to 31.43%. With a 62% graduation rate and higher chronic absenteeism, Berry appears to lose students during the transition to high school. Interestingly, Berry actually spends more per student ($11,769 vs. $10,352) yet performs worse, suggesting funding alone isn't the solution. The district overall ranks in the 60th percentile statewide, but this average masks the wide gap between these two schools serving similar demographics.
Thank you for your feedback!