Summary:
New Market, Alabama, is served by the Madison County school district and is home to 5 schools—three elementary schools (including two PK-6 schools and one grades 3-5 intermediate school), one middle school (grades 7-8), and one high school (grades 9-12)—with a total enrollment of 3,425 students in a predominantly middle-income area.
For parents, the standout choice is Buckhorn High School, which earns a 5-star rating and ranks in the 90th percentile statewide, with a 94.3% graduation rate and English proficiency nearly 16 points above the state average. New Market School is the consistency champion, maintaining a 4-star rating for three years with the district's lowest chronic absenteeism (9.1%) and strong 4th grade science scores (70% proficient). On the other end, Walnut Grove School struggles most, with the highest free/reduced lunch rate (53.1%), highest absenteeism (16.8%), and declining rankings—its 6th grade math proficiency of 25.8% is the district's lowest single-subject score. Buckhorn Middle School and Moores Mill Intermediate School fall in between, with Moores Mill showing strong elementary math (49.3% average) but a significant ranking drop from 116th to 225th statewide.
Key takeaways for families: English instruction is a district-wide strength—every school beats state averages by at least 15 points. However, math proficiency drops sharply from elementary to middle school, with 7th and 8th grade scores falling to 35.1% and 30.8% at Buckhorn Middle, a ~30% decline. Notably, Walnut Grove School receives the highest per-student funding ($12,572) yet produces the weakest outcomes, while Buckhorn Middle School spends the least ($8,221) and outperforms it—suggesting poverty and attendance matter more than spending alone. The two smallest schools get $2,000-$4,000 more per student, but only New Market School justifies that investment. With most schools seeing declining statewide rankings, parents should watch middle school math transitions and attendance patterns closely.
Thank you for your feedback!