Summary
Crystal Lake Elementary School in Lake Mary, FL, is a mid-sized school serving 685 students in grades PK-5 within the highly-rated Seminole County Public Schools district, which ranks in the 89th percentile in Florida.
While Crystal Lake has historically earned 4-star ratings, it has settled into a 3-star rating for the last three years, placing it in a competitive middle ground among nearby schools. The school's most notable challenge is a persistent struggle in 5th-grade math, where proficiency has been alarmingly low and stagnant—reaching just 39% in the most recent year, far below the state average of 62%. This is not an isolated issue, as most nearby schools, including Woodlands Elementary (39%) and Wilson Elementary (44%), also scored below the state average in 5th-grade math, suggesting a broader regional challenge with the curriculum at this level. However, Crystal Lake shows a fascinating strength in its accelerated math program: 6th-grade students (likely advanced learners taking middle school math) have achieved a perfect 100% proficiency for the last two years, indicating the school is highly effective at supporting its top-tier math students even as the general 5th-grade population struggles.
On a positive note, Crystal Lake has a relatively low chronic absenteeism rate of 18.7%, compared to the district's 25.3% and the state's 31.4%, and significantly lower than nearby schools like Idyllwilde Elementary (36.3%). The school also demonstrates that spending does not guarantee performance: it spends a moderate $10,500 per student, while the highest-spending nearby school, Wicklow Elementary ($14,475), has the lowest performance (1-star), and the top-performing Heathrow Elementary (5-star) spends less ($9,780). For parents, Crystal Lake offers a solid, community-focused environment with strong attendance, but the school's "leaky pipeline" in math—where advanced students thrive while others fall behind—suggests an opportunity to investigate what makes its accelerated program successful and apply those strategies more broadly.
Thank you for your feedback!