Summary
Kathleen Middle School in Lakeland, FL, serves 742 students in grades 6-8 and is part of the Polk district, which faces significant challenges statewide. The school has a long history of low performance, ranking in the bottom 10-20% of Florida middle schools over the past decade, and currently holds a 0-star rating. A major concern is chronic absenteeism, with 47.5% of students missing too many days in the 2023-2024 school year—far higher than the state average of 31.4% and dramatically worse than nearby high-performing schools like Lawton Chiles Middle Academy (15.3%) and Berkley Accelerated (17.9%). This absenteeism is strongly linked to low academic achievement, as students who miss school struggle to keep up.
Despite these challenges, Kathleen Middle shows a striking contrast in performance. Students in advanced courses excel: 94% passed Geometry, 89% passed Civics, and 69% passed Algebra 1 on End-of-Course exams, outperforming state averages. However, the majority of students taking standard grade-level FAST exams score well below district and state norms—for example, only 24% of 7th graders and 31% of 8th graders were proficient in math, compared to state averages of 53% and 61%. This suggests a small group of high-achieving students masks the struggles of the general student body. The school also spends more per student ($10,631) than top-performing peers like Lawton Chiles ($9,259) and Berkley Accelerated ($7,956), yet sees lower overall results, indicating resources aren't translating into broad success.
Kathleen Middle is not alone in its struggles; it clusters with other low-performing, high-poverty schools in northern Lakeland, such as Sleepy Hill Middle and Lake Gibson Middle, which share similar absenteeism and test score patterns. In contrast, schools just a few miles away in different socioeconomic areas, like Lakeland Highlands Middle, achieve much better results. There is a small positive sign: the school's rank improved slightly from the 8th to the 10th percentile over the last two years, and most FAST scores saw modest increases (e.g., 6th-grade ELA rose from 33% to 42% proficient). This suggests recent efforts may be starting to help, but the school still has a long way to go.
Thank you for your feedback!