Summary
Plantation Middle School in Plantation, FL, serves 538 students in grades 6-8 and is part of the Broward district, but it has consistently ranked in the bottom quartile of Florida middle schools for the past eight years, earning a 1-star rating. The school faces a severe attendance crisis, with 44.3% of students chronically absent in the 2023-2024 school year—the highest rate among nearby schools and well above the district average of 33.6% and state average of 31.4%. This high absenteeism is likely a primary driver of poor academic performance in standard grade-level courses, where proficiency rates lag significantly behind peers. For example, only 39% of 6th graders were proficient in math, compared to 63% district-wide, and just 31% of 8th graders were proficient in science, versus 49% district-wide.
Despite these challenges, Plantation Middle School shows a striking paradox: it excels in advanced, high-school-level courses. In 2025-2026, 76% of students were proficient in Algebra 1 (above the district’s 68%) and 71% in Geometry (above the district’s 60%). This suggests a highly effective program for a select group of advanced students, while the majority of the student body struggles. The school also spends significantly more per student ($14,485) than higher-performing neighbors like Indian Ridge Middle School ($9,351) and Nova Middle School ($9,853), yet outcomes remain low, pointing to potential inefficiencies in resource allocation or the heavy cost of addressing attendance and poverty-related challenges.
Compared to nearby Seminole Middle School, just 2.45 miles away, Plantation Middle’s struggles are stark. Seminole has a lower poverty rate and lower chronic absenteeism (38.4%), and it outperforms Plantation in nearly every standard subject, ranking in the 51st percentile (3-star) versus Plantation’s 22nd percentile (1-star). While Plantation Middle has shown a slight upward trend from a low of the 12th percentile in 2021-2022 to the 22nd percentile in 2025-2026, it remains far behind its higher-achieving neighbors. For parents, the school offers a strong advanced program for a few, but the overall environment is marked by significant academic struggle and high absenteeism.
Thank you for your feedback!