Summary:
This analysis examines three middle schools in Texarkana, Arkansas, serving grades 4 through 9 across the Texarkana School District and the Genoa Central School District, revealing a stark contrast in academic performance and resources within the same city.
The standout schools are Gary E. Cobb Middle School and Albert J. Murphy Junior High School, both in the Genoa Central district. Gary E. Cobb is a high-performance standout, consistently ranking in the top 5-6% of Arkansas middle schools with a 5-star rating, despite having the lowest per-student spending ($10,451) and the highest student-to-teacher ratio (17.6:1). Albert J. Murphy is a consistent high-achiever, ranking in the 83rd-94th percentile, and excels in advanced coursework—100% of its 8th graders were proficient in Algebra and 81% of its 9th graders in Biology. In contrast, Arkansas Middle School in the Texarkana district is a struggling standout, ranking in the bottom 11-17% of the state with a 1-star rating. It serves a population with 100% free/reduced lunch eligibility and spends the most per student ($14,683) with the lowest student-to-teacher ratio (11.9:1), yet its proficiency rates are roughly one-third of Gary E. Cobb's.
A key takeaway is the poverty-performance paradox: Arkansas Middle School spends 40% more per student than Gary E. Cobb but achieves far lower scores, showing that resources alone cannot overcome the challenges of concentrated poverty. The Genoa Central district's success formula is evident, as both its schools are top-tier, suggesting effective district-wide strategies. Encouragingly, Arkansas Middle School showed year-over-year improvement in all core subjects from 2024-2025 to 2025-2026, a hopeful sign that increased investment may be starting to yield results. This data underscores a deeply divided educational landscape in Texarkana, where outcomes are closely tied to socioeconomic factors.
Thank you for your feedback!